I Tried Superfeet, $600 Custom Orthotics, and Comfort Step. Here's What Let Me Stay Out for All 18.
I walk 18 every Friday with the same three guys. Dale, Mike, and my brother-in-law Tom. Nine years running.
A couple years ago my knee started caving by the 14th. I took short steps so they wouldn't see me limp. The cart was right there, waiting for me to give in.
I wasn't ready to be the guy they play without. So I tried three insoles, one after another, and walked my rounds in each. Here's the honest rundown.
| Superfeet | Custom $600 | Comfort Step | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Firm arch that holds | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ |
| Comfort balance | Partial | ✕ | ✓ |
| Knees & hips | Partial | ✕ | ✓ |
| Walk all 18 | Partial | Partial | ✓ |
| Price + returns | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ |
| Verdict | Close | Overpriced | Winner |
Superfeet
These are the ones everybody points you to, and honestly, for good reason.
- Firm and stable. A lot of walkers genuinely love them: "Superfeet are a game changer."
- "Comfortably walk 18 without any issues." If their shape fits your foot, they're hard to beat for the price.
The good
- It's one fixed arch shape. If it isn't your shape, you feel it higher up. One golfer wrote: "I now walk on the outside of my feet and have hip AND knee pain due to walking on super feet for too long."
- That was me. The arch was high and hard, and by the back nine my knee was still caving.
The catch
Custom Orthotics ($500 to $600)
So I did the "serious" thing. I paid for custom inserts at a clinic.
- For real structural problems they can help: "with them in makes a HUGE difference" walking the course.
- "My calves and hips aren't tight anymore after walking the course."
The good (when done right)
- $600 and "I feel scammed because there's no returns."
- "Too hard... marshmallows, not bricks." Mine were bricks, and went flat inside a year.
- For some they backfire: "it changed my gait... destroying my hips."
The catch
Comfort Step
WinnerDale, the retired PT in our group, slid one out of his own golf shoe. A foot doctor designed it. About fifty bucks, not five hundred.
- It cost about $50, not $600, and I could send it back within 30 days. That made it easy to just try.
- It held up. By the back nine it hadn't gone flat the way the others did. It's rated to hold 330 pounds and keep its shape for over a year, which matched what I felt.
- Firm, but not a brick. There was enough give that my feet weren't wrecked after the round.
What I noticed
- It feels firm. If you're used to soft, cushy insoles, it'll feel different at first.
- Only sold online, so you can't try it on in a store.
- Not a custom mold. For a severe structural problem, you still want a podiatrist.
The catch (so you know)
Why It Worked When the Others Didn't
Dale explained it on the 12th tee. The pain shows up at the knee, but it starts lower down. When the arch falls, the knee rolls in to follow it, and the hip works harder to keep you level. Every step. A round is about 10,000 steps. That's why the back nine is where it gets you.
You don't fix the knee. You fix what's loading it. Comfort Step uses a TriAxis 3-Zone Alignment System:
- HeelLock CradleA deep cup re-centers the heel, so the foot stops rolling in at the source.
- ArchBridge SupportA firm arch props the fallen arch back up, so it stops collapsing with every step.
- FlexForce Forefoot PlateSpreads the load across the ball of the foot, so you've got a solid base to push off through the swing.
When the arch holds, the knee stops caving and the hip stops doing overtime.
From the Foot Doctor Who Designed It
“
I designed Comfort Step Pro to do what I fit $600 custom orthotics to do: support the foot at all three contact points, heel, arch, and forefoot, so the structure above it can line back up. It's the same realignment principle, in a drop-in insole you can wear in the shoes you already own.
Dr. Elliott Marchand
DPM · Designer of Comfort Step Pro
Refined with input from 1,200+ U.S. podiatrists
I'm Not the Only One in the Group
1,200+ U.S. podiatrists approve it · 127,000+ Americans trust Comfort Step · 96% satisfaction · 4.8 / 5 across 668 reviews.
Try Them for 30 Days
Guarantee
Your Offer: Up to 60% Off While This Run Lasts
If you try them, get more than one pair. One for your golf shoes, one for your everyday shoes. They only work when they're under you.
- Single Pair ·
$99.90$49.95 · 50% off - Duo Pair · $89.95 for two · free shipping · free 7-Day Foot-Reset Guide MOST POPULAR
- Tri Pair · $119.95 for three · free shipping · free guide BEST VALUE
Free U.S. shipping on orders over $89. Trim them to fit any shoe.
I'm Ray. I went from eyeing the cart to still walking 18 with my three guys. If you walk your round, see what other walkers are saying before you decide.
COMFORT STEP
This is an advertisement and not an actual news article. The story and person depicted are illustrative; results are not typical and will vary. Quoted experiences are from public forums and reflect individual opinions. Comfort Step insoles support foot alignment and are not a medical device. They are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any condition. If you have ongoing knee, hip, or foot pain, see your doctor.